XP Coin
Earn XP Now

California Governor Says "No" to AI Safety Bill: What Could Go Wrong?

Published at: September 30, 2024

So, here’s the latest scoop: Governor Gavin Newsom of California just vetoed a huge AI safety bill. Yep, the one that would’ve set some serious rules for how tech companies handle artificial intelligence. If you’re wondering what this means, it’s like telling robots and AI companies, "Do your thing...but no one’s watching!"

The bill, called SB 1047 (sounds like a robot’s name, right?), was passed by California lawmakers to keep the most powerful AI models in check. It would’ve required tech companies to take responsibility for any damage caused by their AI systems and even add a “kill switch” for emergencies—like if the AI went rogue and decided to... I don’t know, take over the internet?

But Governor Newsom said, “Nah, thanks.” While he agreed the bill had good intentions, he thought it was a bit too strict for California’s tech industry. According to him, the bill focused too much on the big guys like OpenAI and Google, when smaller AI startups could also be dangerous. He didn’t want to squash innovation—especially from the little guys trying to build the next big thing in AI.

Why Some Folks Are Upset


Senator Scott Wiener, one of the bill's creators, was not happy with the veto. He thinks that letting tech companies police themselves is like leaving a cookie jar in front of kids and expecting them not to dig in. Wiener believes that the risks of AI are too serious to be left unchecked, and without rules, we’re hoping that companies will “do the right thing.” Spoiler: they often don’t. Sure, companies like OpenAI and Meta (Facebook’s parent company) promised to be responsible with their AI. But promises aren’t laws, and Wiener thinks relying on their word isn’t safe for the public.

Related: How’s AI self-regulation going?

Silicon Valley’s Concern: “Don’t Stop Our Innovation!”


Now, not everyone is on board with stricter AI laws. Big names in artificial intelligence development like OpenAI and Google were against the bill from the start. They argued that it would slow down innovation and could even push talented engineers and AI experts to leave California in search of more freedom. After all, the tech world moves fast, and no one wants to feel like they’re being held back by regulations. Jason Kwon from OpenAI said that the bill would threaten growth and that California could lose its title as the home of cutting-edge tech. The message was: “Let us do our thing, or we’ll take our robots and go elsewhere.”

Related: California's AI Bill: A Silicon Valley Showdown

But Wait, Some Tech Leaders Were For the Bill!


On the flip side, not every tech genius was against this law. Elon Musk and some big-time AI researchers like Geoffrey Hinton supported it. They argued that advanced AI could pose serious dangers in the future, from hacking important systems to creating biological weapons. Their argument? It’s better to have safety rules in place now before something goes wrong.

What Happens Next?


Without this law, AI in government and businesses will continue to grow with fewer rules to follow. And while that might be great for innovation, it leaves some pretty big questions unanswered. Will tech companies be responsible if their AI systems cause harm? Who’s watching to make sure AI doesn’t start making dangerous decisions?

Sure, some states like Colorado and Utah have passed laws that address smaller issues like AI bias in hiring or healthcare. But overall, there’s still no nationwide law to regulate the most advanced AI technology. For now, it looks like California’s tech companies will keep doing what they do best—pushing boundaries and hoping nothing goes too wrong.

Related: 14 Risks and Dangers of Artificial Intelligence

Final Thoughts: The AI Rollercoaster Continues


At the end of the day, we’re still riding the wave of artificial intelligence news, and there’s no sign of it slowing down. Governor Newsom may have shut down this AI safety bill, but it’s clear that the debate over the future of AI is just getting started. Will AI companies play nice on their own? Or will we need stronger laws to keep things under control?

Only time will tell. In the meantime, keep an eye on your favourite AI apps and hope they don’t suddenly get any funny ideas.

For further information, click here.

Share Article :

Author Details

Shubham Sahu
Content Writer

Recent Articles

By clicking "Accept", you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage and assist in improving your experience.

Cookies Settings